- Consultants
- Workshop (December 2007)
- Preliminary results/Consultation (February 2008)
- Consultation on the draft transmission to enable renewables report (April 2008)
- Industry briefing (May 2008)
- Final report on the transmission to enable renewables project (Phase 1)
Consultants
The Commission has engaged:
- Connell Wagner to produce a report on wind generation. The report, amongst other things:
- covered national wind resource location, capacity timing factor and possible site development;
- covered issues influencing developer preferences for one site rather than another;
- provided an update on wind generation costs; and
- commented on the Commission's current assumptions about potential wind projects.
- Parsons Brinckerhoff Associates (PBA) to produce a report on hydroelectric generation. The Commission already has a large database of possible hydro schemes. However, the economic assessment of those projects is at a very high level and, in many cases, dated due to technology changes since the original costings were completed. The work carried out by PBA included:
- preparing a shortlist of projects likely to be the most economically feasible. The shortlist is likely to include projects with a Long Run Marginal Cost of less than $100/MWh; and
- estimating capital costs for civil, mechanical, and electrical works or the shortlisted projects (within +/- 30% accuracy).
- The Commission did not engage a geothermal consultant as there was data publicly available which could be used by the Commission’s modelling team in order to produce a report discussing general issues, stakeholders, consenting processes and timing, and estimated cost ranges for consenting for geothermal. The Commission also contacted generators directly to seek this information.
Workshop (December 2007)
A workshop for those interested in the TTER project was held on 17 December 2007 in Wellington and was of both a general and a technical nature.
- Agenda pdf [43 KB] updated 12 December 2007
- Presentation by the Electricity Commission - Project Overview pdf [65 KB]
- Presentation by Parsons Brinckerhoff Associates - Potential hydroelectric generation pdf [1816 KB]
- Presentation by Connell Wagner – Economic wind resource assessment pdf [3290 KB]
- Presentation by the Electricity Commission -Existing and potential geothermal generation pdf [261 KB]
- Presentation by the Electricity Commission – Intermittent generation pdf [313 KB]
- Presentation by System Studies Group – Approach to transmission analysis pdf [369 KB]
- Presentation by Meridian Energy – Case to upgrade Otago – Waitaki transmission pdf [118 KB]
- Presentation by Trustpower pdf [1235 KB]
- Presentation by Transpower pdf [299 KB]
- Presentation by Genesis Energy - Coordination investment renewable generation assets and transmission lines pdf [82 KB
- Presentation by Contact Energy pdf [521 KB]
- Presentation by Neptune Power pdf [426 KB]
- Presentation by Aotearoa Wave and Tidal Energy Association pdf [9442 KB]
- Presentation by Mighty River Power pdf [107 KB]
- Presentation by the Sustainable Energy Forum – The technology defines the resource
pdf [32 KB].
Preliminary results/Consultation(February 2008)
In December 2007, the Commission published for consultation the draft reports on hydro, wind and geothermal generation.
Comments were sought by the Commission by 5pm on Friday 1 February 2008
Consultation on the draft transmission to enable renewables report (April 2008)
In April 2008, the Commission published its draft TTER Report for consultation. The purpose of the draft TTER report was to:
- summarise the feedback received during consultation (written submissions and 17 December 2007 workshop);
- present the finalised geothermal, hydro and wind report updated to reflect the submissions received;
- present the Commission’s response to some of the comments received in submissions;
- present the policy issues identified by the Commission and submitters which require further consideration;
- present the transmission augmentations which would be required to accommodate the potential renewable generation identified and seek comments on it;
- provide a high-level overview of the work undertaken by the Commission to enable transmission investment analysis to consider co-optimisation of transmission and generation investments; and
- seek comments on the additional work and analysis carried out since the previous round of consultation closed.
Comments were sought by the Commission by 5pm on Friday 9 May 2008.
Industry briefing (May 2008)
The Commisison held an industry briefing in Wellington (Intercontinental Hotel, Lambton Room 2, 2 Grey Street, Wellington) on Friday 2 May 2008 (1.30 pm to 4.30 pm) to present the key results of the work.
- Agenda pdf [31 KB].
- Presentation by the Electricity Commission - Transmission to enable renewables pdf [72 KB]
- Presentation by System Studies Group - Generation and transmission opportunities pdf [1208 KB]
- Presentation by the Electricity Commission - Generation and transmission co-optimisation pdf [416 KB]
- Presentation by the Electricity Commission - Wind integration modelling pdf [233 KB]
- Presentation by Transpower - Making the grid planning work pdf [2161 KB]
Final report on the transmission to enable renewables project (Phase 1)
The Commission has completed phase 1 of the transmission to enable renewable project (TTER project) with the publication of the final report and attached consultant reports on the transmission to enable renewables project (Phase 1)
- Final TTER Project Report pdf [452 KB]
- Appendix 2: Final geothermal report "Transmission to enable renewables - Existing and potential geothermal generation in New Zealand" prepared by the Electricity Commission pdf [252 KB]
- Appendix 3: Final hydro report" Transmission to enable renewables - Potential NZ Hydro schemes" prepared by Parsons Brinckerhoff Associates pdf [768 KB]
- Appendix 4: Final wind report "Transmission to enable renewables - Economic wind resource study" prepared by Connell Wagner pdf [2174 KB]
- Appendix 5: Transmission to enable renewables project: Transmission network reinforcement - Inputs for GEM prepared by System Studies Group pdf [161 KB]
The purpose of the Final TTER Project Report is to:
- summarise the feedback received during the consultations carried out on the TTER project (written submissions in February 2008, presentations and feedback from the workshop held on 17 December 2007);
- summarise the issues raised during the second round of submissions (including feedback at the 2 May 2008 workshop) in response to the Commission’s questions and any other matters raised;
- respond to issues raised in the submissions;
- list the policy issues identified by the Commission, including any barriers in the transmission regime to the development of renewable generation; and
- provide an overview of the next phase of the TTER project.
